Identity and Self
Identity is our sense of who we are; the self is the organized set of beliefs we hold about ourselves. The AAMC outline blends psychological and sociological perspectives here: self-concept and self-esteem, the various social identities we hold, the stage theories of development (Erikson, Kohlberg, Vygotsky), and the process of socialization through which we acquire an identity.
Self-Concept and Self-Identity
- Self-concept
- The sum of one’s beliefs about oneself; made of self-schemas. The ideal self vs actual self gap affects self-esteem (Rogers).
- Self-esteem
- One’s overall evaluation of self-worth.
- Self-efficacy
- Belief in one’s ability to succeed at a specific task (Bandura).
- Locus of control
- Internal (outcomes due to own actions) vs external (due to luck/fate).
We hold multiple identities — gender, ethnic, national, religious identities — whose salience shifts by context. Social identity theory (Tajfel) explains how group membership shapes self-concept and produces in-group favoritism.
Theories of Identity Formation
- Cooley — looking-glass self: we form our self-image based on how we think others perceive us.
- Mead — the "I" and the "me": the "I" is the spontaneous self; the "me" is the socialized self shaped by the generalized other. The self develops through play and game stages.
- Trust vs mistrust (infancy)
- Autonomy vs shame/doubt (toddler)
- Initiative vs guilt (preschool)
- Industry vs inferiority (childhood)
- Identity vs role confusion (adolescence)
- Intimacy vs isolation (young adult)
- Generativity vs stagnation (middle adult)
- Integrity vs despair (late adult)
Kohlberg’s moral development: preconventional (obedience/punishment, self-interest), conventional (social approval, law and order), and postconventional (social contract, universal ethical principles). Vygotsky stressed the sociocultural roots of cognition — the zone of proximal development and scaffolding by more knowledgeable others.
Socialization
Socialization is the lifelong process of learning a society’s norms, values and behaviors. Primary socialization occurs in childhood (family); secondary socialization occurs later (school, work). Agents of socialization include family, peers, school, media and religion. Resocialization (e.g., in a total institution like the military or prison) replaces old norms with new ones. Anticipatory socialization prepares us for future roles.
Worked MCQs
Five MCQs covering the high-yield testing patterns for identity and the self.
Q1. A student forms her self-image based on imagining how her classmates judge her. This best illustrates:
Cooley’s looking-glass self describes forming one’s self-concept based on perceptions of how others see us. Mead’s generalized other is the broader societal expectation, a related but distinct concept.
Q2. According to Erikson, the primary psychosocial crisis of adolescence is:
Erikson’s fifth stage, identity vs role confusion, occurs during adolescence and centers on forming a coherent sense of self. Intimacy vs isolation is the young-adult stage.
Q3. A child who says stealing is wrong only because they might get caught and punished is at which Kohlberg level?
Preconventional morality is based on avoiding punishment and self-interest. Conventional morality emphasizes social approval and law/order; postconventional emphasizes abstract ethical principles.
Q4. Confidence in one’s ability to pass a specific chemistry exam is best described as:
Self-efficacy (Bandura) is task-specific belief in one’s capability. Self-esteem is a broader evaluation of overall worth; self-concept is the total set of beliefs about oneself.
Q5. A new military recruit undergoing basic training that strips away civilian habits and instills new norms is experiencing:
Resocialization replaces previously learned norms and values with new ones, often within a total institution such as the military. Primary socialization is early childhood learning within the family.
Quick Recap
- Self-concept (beliefs), self-esteem (worth), self-efficacy (task confidence), locus of control.
- Cooley: looking-glass self; Mead: "I" and "me," generalized other, play/game stages.
- Erikson: 8 stages; adolescence = identity vs role confusion.
- Kohlberg: preconventional → conventional → postconventional.
- Vygotsky: zone of proximal development, scaffolding.
- Socialization: primary, secondary, anticipatory, resocialization (total institutions).
- Agents of socialization: family, peers, school, media, religion.